Online Marketplace for Black Market Cigarettes

Get 10 business ideas daily!

Subscribe to Newsletter

Online Marketplace for Black Market Cigarettes

Inspired by a conversation on:

The Peter Schiff Show Podcast

The Peter Schiff Show Podcast

Share Buyback Chickens Coming Home to Roost – Ep. 412

Host: Peter Schiff

Timestamp: 00:24:53 - 00:29:06

Listen to Episode • View Podcast • All Ideas from The Peter Schiff Show Podcast

Found an idea? We can build it for you.

We design and develop SaaS, AI, and mobile products — from concept to launch in weeks.

Start your project
Feather Flow

Direct Quote

"What stops them from just going online and buying these cigarettes from some business in Canada or Mexico or anywhere else in the world where they're legal?"

Market Gap

Government bans could drive demand for illegal menthol cigarettes.

As governments consider banning certain products like menthol cigarettes, a significant market for these items is likely to develop underground. Smokers who prefer menthols may stockpile them before the ban, suggesting a strong demand for access to these products. Current legal retailers will lose business, while illegal sales could flourish. This situation could lead to increased profits for black market distributors, while also posing health risks to consumers. If these products are banned, it creates a gap that could be filled by an online marketplace that connects consumers to legitimate sources abroad, facilitating legal access despite local restrictions.

Summary

The idea is to create an online marketplace specifically designed for the distribution of menthol cigarettes in regions where they're banned. This platform would connect consumers with suppliers in countries where menthol cigarettes remain legal, allowing them to purchase and have products shipped discreetly to their homes. The marketplace could leverage existing logistics networks to ensure delivery while complying with local regulations regarding tobacco sales. This service would appeal to existing smokers who prefer menthol cigarettes and are seeking ways to continue accessing their preferred products despite legal barriers, creating a potential niche market for continued consumption.

Categorization

Business Model
Marketplace
Target Founder
Generalist
Difficulty
High
Time to Revenue
> 1 year
Initial Investment
$1,000-$10,000

Potential MRR (18-24 months)

Conservative
$5,000 - $10,000 MRR
Moderate (Most Likely)
$15,000 - $30,000 MRR
Optimistic
$40,000 - $70,000 MRR

* Estimates assume solo founder/bootstrap scenario with competent execution

Scores

Clarity
8/10
Novelty
7/10
Feasibility
6/10
Market Potential
8/10
Evidence
7/10
Overall
7/10
Found on September 18, 2025 • Analyzed on September 18, 2025 1:43 AM

Sign In to Access Deep Analysis

Create an account or sign in to request and view detailed business analysis.

Sign In

How should I validate this marketplace idea before building it?

2:34 PM

Great question! For a marketplace idea like this, I'd recommend starting with these validation steps:

  1. Customer interviews: Talk to Generalist to understand their pain points
  2. MVP approach: Build a simple landing page to test demand
  3. Competitor analysis: Research existing solutions and identify gaps

Would you like me to help you create a specific validation plan for your high difficulty idea?

2:35 PM

Yes, and what about the technical implementation? Should I build this myself or hire a team?

2:36 PM

Based on your idea's complexity and > 1 year, here's my recommendation:

Technical Strategy:

  • Start with no-code tools for rapid prototyping
  • Consider your technical background and available $1,000-$10,000
  • Plan for scalability from day one

I can help you create a detailed technical roadmap and resource allocation plan...

2:37 PM

AI Business Coach

Get personalized guidance on implementation, validation, technical decisions, and go-to-market strategies for your business ideas.

∞
Questions
24/7
Availability
GPT-4
AI Model
100%
Private
Subscribe to access Business Coach

Sign In to Access Implementation Roadmap

Create an account or sign in to get personalized implementation guidance.

Sign In

Sign In to Access Market Validation

Create an account or sign in to get comprehensive market analysis and validation strategies.

Sign In

Sign In to Access SEO Strategy

Create an account or sign in to get comprehensive SEO insights including seed keywords and content strategy.

Sign In

Sign In to Access Marketing Prompts

Create an account or sign in to generate ready-to-use marketing prompts for ads, landing pages, email campaigns, and more.

Sign In